XANTIA HDi RUNNING ROUGH

This is the Forum for all your Citroen Technical Questions, Problems or Advice.
User avatar
Stickyfinger
(Donor 2016)
Posts: 11723
Joined: 28 Mar 2013, 21:05
x 1969

Re: XANTIA HDi RUNNING ROUGH

Unread post by Stickyfinger »

Alasdair
Activa, the Moose Dodger
User avatar
Huskyxantia
(Donor 2025)
Posts: 3426
Joined: 30 Jul 2018, 22:11
x 758

Re: XANTIA HDi RUNNING ROUGH

Unread post by Huskyxantia »

Hi, I've just skimmed through this, so the problem is a hole in one of the pistons (crown) what options are being looked at now ? Was you relieved when you found it ? Or was it one of them 🤔 now what do I do moments
Husky. :? Thinking outside of the box is better than sitting in a dark one.
:-D
User avatar
MattBLancs
Donor 2024
Posts: 4981
Joined: 25 Apr 2022, 09:03
x 2177

Re: XANTIA HDi RUNNING ROUGH

Unread post by MattBLancs »

Re question about valve cutouts and if the valves are off to one side.

Quick eBay search here's a second hand cylinder head: they'd not far off central relative to the cylinder bore:
Screenshot_20251219-205656.eBay.png
Copied from:
https://ebay.us/m/qCb6iA.


Re: could you grind that chunk out of that camshaft? I'm not sure how easily that'd be done (would probably seek out a second hand head complete or camshaft if it was me)

Re: not needing to fix it - ah bliss, the rare chance to fix it at your leisure without the stress of not having needed transport available! :-D

Interesting stuff, enjoying being along for the journey
Rhothgar
(Donor 2026)
Posts: 2432
Joined: 22 Nov 2004, 00:21
x 225

Re: XANTIA HDi RUNNING ROUGH

Unread post by Rhothgar »

Huskyxantia wrote: 19 Dec 2025, 20:46 Hi, I've just skimmed through this, so the problem is a hole in one of the pistons (crown) what options are being looked at now ? Was you relieved when you found it ? Or was it one of them 🤔 now what do I do moments
There isn’t a hole in the piston. Unless something has changed since last week.
Rhothgar
(Donor 2026)
Posts: 2432
Joined: 22 Nov 2004, 00:21
x 225

Re: XANTIA HDi RUNNING ROUGH

Unread post by Rhothgar »

MattBLancs wrote: 19 Dec 2025, 21:02 Re question about valve cutouts and if the valves are off to one side.

Quick eBay search here's a second hand cylinder head: they'd not far off central relative to the cylinder bore:
Image
Copied from:
https://ebay.us/m/qCb6iA.


Re: could you grind that chunk out of that camshaft? I'm not sure how easily that'd be done (would probably seek out a second hand head complete or camshaft if it was me)

Re: not needing to fix it - ah bliss, the rare chance to fix it at your leisure without the stress of not having needed transport available! :-D

Interesting stuff, enjoying being along for the journey
This nicely proves that the oil slick is on the correct side of the piston ie to the rear.
User avatar
Huskyxantia
(Donor 2025)
Posts: 3426
Joined: 30 Jul 2018, 22:11
x 758

Re: XANTIA HDi RUNNING ROUGH

Unread post by Huskyxantia »

Rhothgar wrote: 22 Dec 2025, 10:03
Huskyxantia wrote: 19 Dec 2025, 20:46 Hi, I've just skimmed through this, so the problem is a hole in one of the pistons (crown) what options are being looked at now ? Was you relieved when you found it ? Or was it one of them 🤔 now what do I do moments
There isn’t a hole in the piston. Unless something has changed since last week.
Accept my apology, it looked like a hole in the piston from what I saw , what's your overall plan for the cars outcome ?
Husky. :? Thinking outside of the box is better than sitting in a dark one.
:-D
Rhothgar
(Donor 2026)
Posts: 2432
Joined: 22 Nov 2004, 00:21
x 225

Re: XANTIA HDi RUNNING ROUGH

Unread post by Rhothgar »

Rhothgar wrote: 18 Dec 2025, 13:09
Skull wrote: 18 Dec 2025, 11:49 Rothgar

I'm still alive ...I haven't got any further yet and am having real motivation/debating my sanity problems, I can't decide whether to call the men in white coats to take me away :lol: . I think the biggest problem I have, is that I don't need the car to get around, we have 2 other cars so it's surplus, I've never been in this position before...normally I need to fix the car so just crack on. It's only curiosity that is tempting me to do the strip down.

I hope you haven't had the same trouble with your Tax Return :twisted:
I've already made representations for them to take me away.

Finished the accounts last night and emailed to accountant for number-crunching and CT preparation and 2.5 months early. That's a first for Mr. Procrastinator.
Rhothgar
(Donor 2026)
Posts: 2432
Joined: 22 Nov 2004, 00:21
x 225

Re: XANTIA HDi RUNNING ROUGH

Unread post by Rhothgar »

Huskyxantia wrote: 22 Dec 2025, 12:02
Rhothgar wrote: 22 Dec 2025, 10:03
Huskyxantia wrote: 19 Dec 2025, 20:46 Hi, I've just skimmed through this, so the problem is a hole in one of the pistons (crown) what options are being looked at now ? Was you relieved when you found it ? Or was it one of them 🤔 now what do I do moments
There isn’t a hole in the piston. Unless something has changed since last week.
Accept my apology, it looked like a hole in the piston from what I saw , what's your overall plan for the cars outcome ?
Skull was worried about it being a holed piston initially as he thought he had seen a shard of metal in one of the photos but it turned out it was just the edge of the valve relief pattern in the top of the piston.

He's planning on fixing I believe when the men in white coats release him from his shackles...

Hopefully not a biggie but the jury's out on whether he's taking the head off to do further checks or just replacing the cam follower and hoping for the best. The Jim / Mick camp is for "off with its head" whereas a couple of us as "softly, softly" approach (why do more work than necessary). This is providing he can recover the end of his mirror with a mini-grabber type affair which fell into the black hole when he stuck his who-ji-ma-flop in there....

Oooh matron! Sounds painful!
User avatar
Skull
(Donor 2026)
Posts: 1354
Joined: 02 Aug 2013, 13:35
x 368

Re: XANTIA HDi RUNNING ROUGH

Unread post by Skull »

Sorry if I've been ignoring anyone or the thread but I have been trying to get stuck in when the weather and free time coinside.

Rothgar I will not allow your Jedi mind powers to persuade me .... I have not decided what to do regarding repairs, those of you who think a Cam Follower would be worth a try might be right IF I had compression there's a good chance of that, I can't do another compression test now as the Camshaft is removed and the Piston is obstructed by either the mirror stuck in there :oops: or (sounds like) something stronger in the way, I've tried to manually crank it and crush the plastic mirror but I get the 'feeling' something solid is in the way....plus I will lose position of the TDC on it's Compression stroke.

XantiaHusky No need for apologies it does look like a holed piston to me, so we might still be right :roll: ....What will happen to the car all depends on the extent of engine damage...It's MoT'd until 26 JUL 26 :shock:

So currently a further strip down is underway...Exhaust Cat removed, Driveshaft is out - made more akward and nerve-racking as the suspension is still pressurised.

Normally I would depressurise but I need clearance for any future loading that might be required. It's on ramps AND axle stands as stable as I can get her ...
Skull's - Rear of Engine view
Skull's - Rear of Engine view
Not much further today as I've had to admit defeat on the Turbo Oil Feed line which is secured with a banjo type braided hose of unknown torque and despite my improvised tools requires a 14mm Hex Sump Key (another tool to buy despite my vast collection)...
Skull's - More tools required
Skull's - More tools required
The Men In White Coats are having Christmas anyway .... :Santa: :rudolf: :snowman: Merry Christmas FCF
Last edited by Skull on 22 Dec 2025, 17:53, edited 1 time in total.
My 4th Citroën Xantia (X2 HDi (110))
My 5th Citroën sAXo Memphis Mk II

Xantia x3 (2.0i TCT Activa)(2.1 TD SX)(1.9 TD Estate)
Xsara HDi VTR Coupe / Saxo 1.1i / BX 1.9 d / 4 x AX's (1.1i / 1.4D / 1.5D)

Gary
Rhothgar
(Donor 2026)
Posts: 2432
Joined: 22 Nov 2004, 00:21
x 225

Re: XANTIA HDi RUNNING ROUGH

Unread post by Rhothgar »

Skull wrote: 22 Dec 2025, 17:19 Rothgar I will not allow your Jedi mind powers to persuade me ....
🤪
FCF - You will never find a more wretched hive of scum and villainy. We must be cautious.

How long have you had these French cars?

About 3 or 4 seasons. They’re not for sale.

These aren’t the cam followers you are looking for.
User avatar
moizeau
Donor 2024
Posts: 1851
Joined: 12 Jan 2015, 16:08
x 427

Re: XANTIA HDi RUNNING ROUGH

Unread post by moizeau »

Whatever you find, it won't be as bad as this
100_8071.JPG
or this
100_8079.JPG
Cams are out, chuck some air down the cylinders
Pete
Notice the BX is still top the list but sadly gone
User avatar
Skull
(Donor 2026)
Posts: 1354
Joined: 02 Aug 2013, 13:35
x 368

Re: XANTIA HDi RUNNING ROUGH

Unread post by Skull »

:( No it won't be that bad Pete ...Mine was still running :roll:
My 4th Citroën Xantia (X2 HDi (110))
My 5th Citroën sAXo Memphis Mk II

Xantia x3 (2.0i TCT Activa)(2.1 TD SX)(1.9 TD Estate)
Xsara HDi VTR Coupe / Saxo 1.1i / BX 1.9 d / 4 x AX's (1.1i / 1.4D / 1.5D)

Gary
User avatar
CitroJim
A very naughty boy
Posts: 54567
Joined: 30 Apr 2005, 23:33
x 8088

Re: XANTIA HDi RUNNING ROUGH

Unread post by CitroJim »

moizeau wrote: 22 Dec 2025, 17:54 Whatever you find, it won't be as bad as this
Gosh Pete :shock: whatever happened there?
Jim

A bit of a Citroen AX fan...
User avatar
moizeau
Donor 2024
Posts: 1851
Joined: 12 Jan 2015, 16:08
x 427

Re: XANTIA HDi RUNNING ROUGH

Unread post by moizeau »

CitroJim wrote: 23 Dec 2025, 05:44

Gosh Pete :shock: whatever happened there?
I bought the bike with a siezed engine. It had only done 5000kms since having a top end rebuild and new Wiseco pistons. The 'mechanic' (using the term in the loosest way possible) didn't know his arris from a hole in the ground. He either partially removed the camchain tensioner then refitted it of fitted the tensioner before fitting the valve cover. Either of these will cause the camchain to be massively over tensioned. This caused the camchain to be pulled into the head slowly eating away at the cam journals which then jumped down the middle of the engine and made love with the crank, breaking a shim and pushing the valve cover off in the process. The PO did say it was rather spectacular!
100_8093.JPG
100_8100.JPG
It did mean I got my fuel injected GPz1100 from 1983 for just a little bit more than the price of the 1170cc Wiseco kit. Fiding a new head was fun, the bike was only made for 3 years but one turned up thanks to a chap in the Z1 Owners Club.
It's currently going through a complete rebuild, every nut and bolt frame and engine.
A long job with a few more hard to find parts to source but it will be worth it.

There you go Jim, bet you'd never asked now :rofl2:
Pete
Notice the BX is still top the list but sadly gone
Rhothgar
(Donor 2026)
Posts: 2432
Joined: 22 Nov 2004, 00:21
x 225

Re: XANTIA HDi RUNNING ROUGH

Unread post by Rhothgar »

moizeau wrote: 23 Dec 2025, 06:26 It did mean I got my fuel injected GPz1100 from 1983 for just a little bit more than the price of the 1170cc Wiseco kit.
What a find! A bonkers bike in its day and probably still beat a fair few modern bikes in acceleration over the 1/4 mile.