Tales from beyond the grave AKA Dan & Emma's Black Xantia, pug 206HDi, Daniel's 206 Verve 1.4i, GTi180 plus XUD9TE 206!!

Tell us your ongoing tales and experiences with your French car here. Post pictures of your car here as well.
User avatar
CitroJim
A very naughty boy
Posts: 55182
Joined: 30 Apr 2005, 23:33
x 8440

Re: Tales from beyond the grave AKA Dan & Emma's Black Xantia, pug 206HDi, Daniel's 206 Verve 1.4i, GTi180 plus XUD9TE 2

Post by CitroJim »

That's superb news Dan :D
Jim

A bit of a Citroen AX fan...
ekjdm14
(Donor 2020)
Posts: 2045
Joined: 19 Jan 2015, 17:42
x 271

Re: Tales from beyond the grave AKA Dan & Emma's Black Xantia, pug 206HDi, Daniel's 206 Verve 1.4i, GTi180 plus XUD9TE 2

Post by ekjdm14 »

Well pleased to once again be "back in Black" :D

Heater isn't all I remember it being, although I think that's to do with the foam being missing off the blend door & recirc door judging by the click/knock they make on closing rather than the soft thud one normally hears. Other than that all's well so far & nice & comfy once again (spits on Focus seat) :rofl2:

EDIT-: just popped out and swapped the bodged positive battery cable to a better bodge as the body electrics were getting iffy & starter didn't engage 100% Got a nice quick-connect terminal on there now too.
'95 Xantia LX 1.9D-auto, Black, 123k
'97 306 XS 1.6i, Blaze Yellow, 29k
'96 ZX SX 1.9TD, White, 90k
'98 306 1.9D, Cherry Red, 180?k
'05 "Fraud Fuco" Focus stopgap/beater
'12 Mini freebie project
ekjdm14
(Donor 2020)
Posts: 2045
Joined: 19 Jan 2015, 17:42
x 271

Re: Tales from beyond the grave AKA Dan & Emma's Black Xantia, pug 206HDi, Daniel's 206 Verve 1.4i, GTi180 plus XUD9TE 2

Post by ekjdm14 »

With Black now pronounced "reliable" once more, I took the opportunity to drop the sump off the Bin-i this afternoon. As predicted the failure was again on #3, although not nearly as bad this time. Bearing hasn't spun this go around, and has basically just eaten the upper shell leaving the lower one with light scarring.

From the wear pattern (very even across the upper shell, probably taken over 10 thou off it though as it's to the copper already but *not quite* as bad close to the parting lines & lower shell same pattern and almost run-able if it hadn't had bits of the upper pick up on it), taken along with the previous failure on that cylinder, I'm hopeful that the rod itself isn't deformed (ovality in the rod bore would tend to pinch worse at the parting line and from what I've read this pattern is almost textbook injector failure symptoms.

Why I didn't hear it "nailing" at idle/free revving (and why it lasted fine on the driveway and died after only a couple of pulls under boost) would be thanks to the ECU having the ability to correct slightly for individual injectors at idle for "smooth running" and rail pressure being lower too... So basically I think with the crank cleaned up and the one shell replaced again (it's having one of the good used ones this time!) it'll need the injectors taken in and tested/refurbed/replaced and maybe will manage to make it more than a mile down the road finally. Be pretty nice as it's got MoT to take us through till end of Feb. so can keep the salt away from Black!
'95 Xantia LX 1.9D-auto, Black, 123k
'97 306 XS 1.6i, Blaze Yellow, 29k
'96 ZX SX 1.9TD, White, 90k
'98 306 1.9D, Cherry Red, 180?k
'05 "Fraud Fuco" Focus stopgap/beater
'12 Mini freebie project
User avatar
CitroJim
A very naughty boy
Posts: 55182
Joined: 30 Apr 2005, 23:33
x 8440

Re: Tales from beyond the grave AKA Dan & Emma's Black Xantia, pug 206HDi, Daniel's 206 Verve 1.4i, GTi180 plus XUD9TE 2

Post by CitroJim »

This remains rather an interesting and intriguing mystery on the No.3 big end bearing fails on the Bini Dan..

I wonder if the journal has worn oval or perhaps the bearing housing in the block and/or the bearing cap has become distorted as a result of the original bearing shell spin? Getting a micrometer on it might be revealing.

More intriguing that it's the upper shell that's suffered more... Logic would say the more wear would be on the lower shell based on the belief there's more thrust loading with the piston descending on the firing stroke.

We know the failure was not due to a lubrication failure due to blockages/restrictions in the oilways so maybe the bearing failure was due to too-tight a clearance in the bearing leading to indirect lubrication failure. A journal that's worn oval or distortion in the housing could conceivably cause this... Time to get the plastigage out...

It could still be due to a partial blockage in the oilway leading to that journal... A bit like a person suffering furred-up arteries...

I'm fascinated by this and I trust you don't mind me thinking out loud on the possible causes...
Jim

A bit of a Citroen AX fan...
ekjdm14
(Donor 2020)
Posts: 2045
Joined: 19 Jan 2015, 17:42
x 271

Re: Tales from beyond the grave AKA Dan & Emma's Black Xantia, pug 206HDi, Daniel's 206 Verve 1.4i, GTi180 plus XUD9TE 2

Post by ekjdm14 »

CitroJim wrote: Yesterday, 13:39 This remains rather an interesting and intriguing mystery on the No.3 big end bearing fails on the Bini Dan..

I wonder if the journal has worn oval or perhaps the bearing housing in the block and/or the bearing cap has become distorted as a result of the original bearing shell spin? Getting a micrometer on it might be revealing.

Sadly don't own one myself, but will have a word with a neighbour and see if he's got one I could borrow (as well as a telescopic to check the rod housing

More intriguing that it's the upper shell that's suffered more... Logic would say the more wear would be on the lower shell based on the belief there's more thrust loading with the piston descending on the firing stroke.

Brain fart on your part I fear, Jim. Thrust on firing stroke loads upper shell on a rod :wink:

We know the failure was not due to a lubrication failure due to blockages/restrictions in the oilways so maybe the bearing failure was due to too-tight a clearance in the bearing leading to indirect lubrication failure. A journal that's worn oval or distortion in the housing could conceivably cause this... Time to get the plastigage out...

Clearance checked in-spec on reassembly, but only in a couple of spots. If mic isn't available then will plastigage in as many different positions as possible

It could still be due to a partial blockage in the oilway leading to that journal... A bit like a person suffering furred-up arteries...

Possibly, there was good amount of oil on the bearing but will double-triple check anyhow

I'm fascinated by this and I trust you don't mind me thinking out loud on the possible causes...
On the final point, of course not Jim. Your thoughts (and anyone else who happens to chime in) are more than welcome, it's good to have some other human input to go along with my own research & AI's responses. :)

It's from AI that I got the idea of it being the injector TBH, because my first thought (and "it's" first suggestion) was distortion to the housing BUT the wear pattern from a distorted rod would tend to pinch at the parting line relief area & chew the bearings up worse on the ends, whereas the upper shell is fairly evenly wiped out, maybe a little better either end.
'95 Xantia LX 1.9D-auto, Black, 123k
'97 306 XS 1.6i, Blaze Yellow, 29k
'96 ZX SX 1.9TD, White, 90k
'98 306 1.9D, Cherry Red, 180?k
'05 "Fraud Fuco" Focus stopgap/beater
'12 Mini freebie project
User avatar
mickthemaverick
Forum Admin Team
Posts: 21367
Joined: 11 May 2019, 17:56
x 8164

Re: Tales from beyond the grave AKA Dan & Emma's Black Xantia, pug 206HDi, Daniel's 206 Verve 1.4i, GTi180 plus XUD9TE 2

Post by mickthemaverick »

This is in my regular auction house's sale on Wednesday Dan

https://www.i-bidder.com/en-gb/auction- ... f900ca8c8e :)
I used to be indecisive, now I'm not so sure!
I used to ride on two wheels, but now I need all four!
User avatar
CitroJim
A very naughty boy
Posts: 55182
Joined: 30 Apr 2005, 23:33
x 8440

Re: Tales from beyond the grave AKA Dan & Emma's Black Xantia, pug 206HDi, Daniel's 206 Verve 1.4i, GTi180 plus XUD9TE 2

Post by CitroJim »

Yep, you're right I got it wrong on the firing stroke thrust Dan ;) Doh!
Jim

A bit of a Citroen AX fan...
User avatar
mickthemaverick
Forum Admin Team
Posts: 21367
Joined: 11 May 2019, 17:56
x 8164

Re: Tales from beyond the grave AKA Dan & Emma's Black Xantia, pug 206HDi, Daniel's 206 Verve 1.4i, GTi180 plus XUD9TE 2

Post by mickthemaverick »

In fact, thinking about this I believe the upper shell takes the force on 3 out of the four strokes, only when the crank is pulling on the piston rod, ie induction, does the lower shell take the force?:

Induction - crank pulling piston - force on lower
Compression - crank pushing piston - force on upper
Combustion - piston pushing crank - force on upper
Exhaust - crank pushing piston - force on upper

That's my thinking, right or wrong? :)
I used to be indecisive, now I'm not so sure!
I used to ride on two wheels, but now I need all four!
User avatar
mickthemaverick
Forum Admin Team
Posts: 21367
Joined: 11 May 2019, 17:56
x 8164

Re: Tales from beyond the grave AKA Dan & Emma's Black Xantia, pug 206HDi, Daniel's 206 Verve 1.4i, GTi180 plus XUD9TE 2

Post by mickthemaverick »

While thinking about the above another thought ocurred to me, just thinking aloud. If number 3 piston has a 'higher top' due to a fault of various possibilities, it would get higher compression than the other cylinders and hence produce more force on combustion? Corrosion, over long rod, thicker lower shells, misshaped head are all possibilities? :?
I used to be indecisive, now I'm not so sure!
I used to ride on two wheels, but now I need all four!