Dodgy MOT?

This is the Forum for all your Citroen Technical Questions, Problems or Advice.

Moderator: RichardW

Post Reply
User avatar
Bandit12
(Donor 2020)
Posts: 394
Joined: 23 Apr 2013, 11:35
Location: Stevenage
My Cars: C5 X7 diesel exclusive
x 12

Dodgy MOT?

Post by Bandit12 »

My c5 passed her MOT a couple of weeks ago with flying colours. Great news you might think, however within a week I was greeted with the sound of metal on metal from the front brakes. I flipped the drivers wheel off n found the brakes had no metal and gouged a nice groove into the disc! I challenged the MOT station who said that due to the lack of visibility through the alloys they could not visually check the brakes but car passed so what's the problem?
Can a car pass a proper MOT with brakes like that?
Needless to say I've replaced the pads etc
Bandit
2002 Citroen C5 2.2Hdi exclusive estate (sadly gone) :(
2009 Citroën C5 X7 2.0 hdi (136bhp) exclusive estate (Oh wow what an upgrade) 8-)
MikeT
Posts: 4809
Joined: 11 Jun 2007, 16:17
Location: Christchurch, Dorset. UK
My Cars: 2005 C5restyle 1.6HDI 16v 110hp VTR Estate
2008 C5 X7 1.6HDI VTR+ Saloon
x 231

Re: Dodgy MOT?

Post by MikeT »

As long as the brakes performed satisfactorily in the test and nothing untoward is seen, it's a pass.

I got an advisory on low pads last year. I replaced them just before this years test, but due to a caliper piston rewind failure, had to refit one worn pad and it still passed, this time with no advisory. I think when I looked (through the alloy wheel spokes) I could only see the outer pad while the worn one was re-fitted on the inside.
Last edited by MikeT on 03 Jul 2017, 16:06, edited 1 time in total.
User avatar
CitroJim
A very naughty boy
Posts: 49526
Joined: 30 Apr 2005, 23:33
Location: Paggers
My Cars: Bluebell the AX, Polly the C3 Picasso, Pix the Nissan Pixo, Propel the duathlon bike, TCR Pro the road bike and Fuji the TT bike...
x 6160
Contact:

Re: Dodgy MOT?

Post by CitroJim »

I got an an advisory on both my 207 and Sian's Pixo for worn brake pads... Even though in my opinion there was still a good bit of pad left on both... There still is on the 207 - I checked only yesterday...

But as Mike says, as long as they're OK on the day and also, it depends on the tester and how visible the pads are when the MOT is conducted.. Some are well hidden from view without removing the wheel - which they cannot do.
Jim

Runner, cyclist, time triallist, duathlete, Citroen AX fan and the CCC Citroenian 'From A to Z' Columnist...
ekjdm14
(Donor 2020)
Posts: 1810
Joined: 19 Jan 2015, 17:42
Location: Congleton
Lexia Available: Yes
My Cars: '95 Xantia 1.9D automatic - 109k one of two remaining
'03 206 GTi180 - 97k in pieces being brought back up to snuff
'03 206 1.9TD - home-built veg-fuelled B-road bruiser
'99 306 SE 2.0i cabriolet - 92k awaiting service work ready for next summer
'97 306 XS 1.6i 3 door, Bianca White, from dead 12 years & seized solid to road legal in 7 days
x 212

Re: Dodgy MOT?

Post by ekjdm14 »

CitroJim wrote: 03 Jul 2017, 12:58.... Some are well hidden from view without removing the wheel - which they cannot do.


Xantia/XM on steel wheels are a prime example of just this. I defy any tester to measure/see/feel/hear or otherwise judge the amount of pad or disc material left on one of these cars or the condition of anything behind the shield, other than by the performance of the brakes on the roller.

I think in that case as long as the brakes were balanced and strong enough, even the grinding sound of metal on metal could only be listed as advisory since the MoT stipulates a kind of "if in doubt, pass with advise" sort of thing. (like sideskirts over rotten sills too)
'95 Xantia LX 1.9D-auto, Black, 109k
'03 206 GTi180 94k in surgery
'03 206 1.1S XUD9TE/veg project :mrgreen:
'99 306 2.0SE cabriolet 95k summer toy
'97 306 XS 1.6i 99k sat 12 years, fixed in 7 days, 150mile maiden voyage :rofl2:
Bick
Posts: 482
Joined: 19 Feb 2006, 17:35
Location:
My Cars:
x 44

Re: Dodgy MOT?

Post by Bick »

Minimum lining required for pads is 1mm - if they cant see them they cant inspect it - an MOT is not a service.
Peter.N.
Moderating Team
Posts: 11563
Joined: 02 Apr 2005, 16:11
Location: Charmouth,Dorset
My Cars: Currently:

C5 X7 VTR + Satnav Hdi estate Silver
C5 X7 VTR + Hdi Estate 2008 Red

In the past: 3, CX td Safaris and about 7, XM td estates. Lovely cars.
x 1199

Re: Dodgy MOT?

Post by Peter.N. »

I would rather have an MOT tester like that than one who fails it on non existent problems so he can make money out of you.

Peter
Online
User avatar
Zelandeth
Donor 2024
Posts: 4731
Joined: 16 Nov 2014, 23:36
Location: Milton Keynes
My Cars: 2006 Peugeot Partner Escapade 1.6HDi.
1988 Renault 25 Monaco 2.0i.
1985 Sinclair C5.
1984 Trabant 601S.
1975 Rover 3500.
1973 AC Model-70.
x 1403
Contact:

Re: Dodgy MOT?

Post by Zelandeth »

As others have said, if the pads aren't readily visible without removing the wheel no visual inspection will be done and the pass/fail will be purely based on the performance on the rollers.

So provided your brakes worked fine at the test, this is quite normal.
Current fleet:
06 Peugeot Partner Escapade 1.6HDi, 88 Renault 25 Monaco, 85 Sinclair C5, 84 Trabant 601S, 75 Rover 3500, 73 AC Model 70.
User avatar
van ordinaire
(Donor 2017)
Posts: 2537
Joined: 23 Jun 2015, 14:45
Location: Live & work in London but weekend in Devon (or do I now live in Torbay & work in London?)
My Cars: Citroens:-
'81 2CV Club (quietly sleeping in a parallel universe)
'05 (yes, really) C15
'97 Xantia Exclusive estate
others:-
'96 Jeep Cherokee Limited - the "donor"
'99 Jeep Cherokee Orvis - the green one
'97 Jeep Cherokee Limited - the red one
'99 Cadillac Seville STS
'96 Cadillac Eldorado ETC
& numerous what might be described as abandoned projects!
x 405

Re: Dodgy MOT?

Post by van ordinaire »

Can't see how pads with so little meat on them could pass.

b-t-w, don't C5's have a low pad warning light?
Citroens:-
'81 2CV Club :cry:
'05 C15 :!:
'97 Xantia Exclusive estate [-o<
others:-
Jeep XJ Cherokees x 3 :?
'96 Cadillac Eldorado
'99 Cadillac STS :|
& the numerous "abandoned projects" #-o
elma
Posts: 3745
Joined: 13 May 2007, 02:17
Location: United Kingdom
My Cars: Undisclosed
x 287

Re: Dodgy MOT?

Post by elma »

Only if the wires connected, I never bother with them because I replace pads at 1/2 thickness unless the discs are knackered.
User avatar
Paul-R
Donor 2023
Posts: 6916
Joined: 07 May 2009, 16:24
Location: Wirral, NW England; Vaucluse 84, France
Lexia Available: Yes
My Cars: 2015 1.6 Blue HDi 120 Peugeot 308 Active SW
2013 2.0 HDi 163 C5 Exclusive Tourer
2003 2.0 HDi 110 C5 Exclusive Estate (Gone)
2001 2.0 HDi 90 Xsara Estate (Gone)
x 1369

Re: Dodgy MOT?

Post by Paul-R »

Can I have your half-worn pads please? :rofl2:
As I get older I think a lot about the hereafter - I go into a room and then wonder what I'm here after.

Inside every old person is a young person wondering what the hell happened.

"Trying is the first step towards failure" ~ Homer J Simpson​
elma
Posts: 3745
Joined: 13 May 2007, 02:17
Location: United Kingdom
My Cars: Undisclosed
x 287

Re: Dodgy MOT?

Post by elma »

No problem, be 6 months or more though. Current discs are rubbish so will be the next set.
Gives you plenty of time to find a nice Xantia V6, theres a pretty grey one on ebay.
User avatar
van ordinaire
(Donor 2017)
Posts: 2537
Joined: 23 Jun 2015, 14:45
Location: Live & work in London but weekend in Devon (or do I now live in Torbay & work in London?)
My Cars: Citroens:-
'81 2CV Club (quietly sleeping in a parallel universe)
'05 (yes, really) C15
'97 Xantia Exclusive estate
others:-
'96 Jeep Cherokee Limited - the "donor"
'99 Jeep Cherokee Orvis - the green one
'97 Jeep Cherokee Limited - the red one
'99 Cadillac Seville STS
'96 Cadillac Eldorado ETC
& numerous what might be described as abandoned projects!
x 405

Re: Dodgy MOT?

Post by van ordinaire »

Don't follow the logic of not connecting the sensors just because you're not going to rely on them.

I quite like the extra security against being caught out by premature wear due to a seized caliper, e.g.
Citroens:-
'81 2CV Club :cry:
'05 C15 :!:
'97 Xantia Exclusive estate [-o<
others:-
Jeep XJ Cherokees x 3 :?
'96 Cadillac Eldorado
'99 Cadillac STS :|
& the numerous "abandoned projects" #-o
elma
Posts: 3745
Joined: 13 May 2007, 02:17
Location: United Kingdom
My Cars: Undisclosed
x 287

Re: Dodgy MOT?

Post by elma »

I've only ever had them tell me the pads are worn when they are not or not tell me they are worn when they are in desperate need of replacement.

They just are not something I trust and I can't be bothered to fit something I think is pointless and untrustworthy when I can see and feel any brake issues myself.

I probably spend more time tinkering with my cars than driving them so I'm confident that in my case the wear sensing wires are unnecessary.
Peter.N.
Moderating Team
Posts: 11563
Joined: 02 Apr 2005, 16:11
Location: Charmouth,Dorset
My Cars: Currently:

C5 X7 VTR + Satnav Hdi estate Silver
C5 X7 VTR + Hdi Estate 2008 Red

In the past: 3, CX td Safaris and about 7, XM td estates. Lovely cars.
x 1199

Re: Dodgy MOT?

Post by Peter.N. »

I can't recall ever having a car on which the 'worn pad' indicator actually worked, even though the wires were connected, there may have been one I have forgotten but as a general rule the don't work. Doesn't matter a lot in my case as my pads last so long I'm bound to need the wheel off for something before they are worn out.

Peter
ekjdm14
(Donor 2020)
Posts: 1810
Joined: 19 Jan 2015, 17:42
Location: Congleton
Lexia Available: Yes
My Cars: '95 Xantia 1.9D automatic - 109k one of two remaining
'03 206 GTi180 - 97k in pieces being brought back up to snuff
'03 206 1.9TD - home-built veg-fuelled B-road bruiser
'99 306 SE 2.0i cabriolet - 92k awaiting service work ready for next summer
'97 306 XS 1.6i 3 door, Bianca White, from dead 12 years & seized solid to road legal in 7 days
x 212

Re: Dodgy MOT?

Post by ekjdm14 »

The light worked OK on Black, problem was that the pads/discs & fitting kit were all brand new with under 250miles on them at the time!

I only connected up the wear sensors because they were included with the pads I chose, sadly the offside wire got chewed through in short order. I think it may have been different had we got alloys on there but the standard 14" steels have virtually zero caliper clearance at the front & I think the over-long wire got pinched between that & the wheel.

I think they are a useful thing to have, if only because the light being on can facilitate an MoT tester to fail a car on which he otherwise couldn't see the pads. Even if it's a spurious warning, at least it gets the wheel taken off for a look-see & the retest oughtn't cost the driver anything, potentially could save them a lot of money on new discs/fitting or even a life though. Myself, I try to have them working/functional if possible but otherwise I'm likely to see them getting low & replace while a wheel is off for something else.
'95 Xantia LX 1.9D-auto, Black, 109k
'03 206 GTi180 94k in surgery
'03 206 1.1S XUD9TE/veg project :mrgreen:
'99 306 2.0SE cabriolet 95k summer toy
'97 306 XS 1.6i 99k sat 12 years, fixed in 7 days, 150mile maiden voyage :rofl2:
Post Reply