Are 1.9D Synergie and Peugeot 405 Starter Motors the same?

[kenbw2]

My starter motor is showing signs of being on its way out and I can harvest one from a spares repairs Peugeot 405. They're both the XUD engine so I'd assume they're one and the same

Can anyone confirm one way or the other?

[Stewart(oily)]

All of the diesel ones seem interchangeable, though some of the older ones are longer in the body.

[kenbw2]

Is that extra length something that can cause a problem, or is the space sufficient for both?

[citronut]

here is a the list of pugs that comes up on an all families search on Pug service box

all these are diesel's

with this part No.
5802 M3

4 document(s) found for 406
3 document(s) found for 307 RESTYLING
2 document(s) found for BOXER 2
1 document(s) found for 605
1 document(s) found for 205
1 document(s) found for 605
4 document(s) found for 807
2 document(s) found for PARTNER VP (M59)
1 document(s) found for 405 SAUF RESTYL
1 document(s) found for 309
2 document(s) found for 206
1 document(s) found for 405
2 document(s) found for 307
3 document(s) found for 306
2 document(s) found for PARTNER
1 document(s) found for 205 A PARTIR MOD 1991
2 document(s) found for PARTNER VU (M59)
3 document(s) found for 406 (RESTYLING)
1 document(s) found for 607
2 document(s) found for 407
1 document(s) found for 4007
8 document(s) found for 306 (RESTYLING)
1 document(s) found for 607 RESTYLING
2 document(s) found for EXPERT
2 document(s) found for BOXER
1 document(s) found for J5-Express
2 document(s) found for 806

and the same on service citroen

5802 M3

3 document(s) found for BX
5 document(s) found for C25
1 document(s) found for XSARA II
3 document(s) found for C5 II
1 document(s) found for C4 PICASSO
1 document(s) found for XM
2 document(s) found for C15
2 document(s) found for BERLINGO VU (M59)
2 document(s) found for XANTIA II
2 document(s) found for RELAY
3 document(s) found for C4
1 document(s) found for C-CROSSER
1 document(s) found for XANTIA
2 document(s) found for SYNERGIE
4 document(s) found for C8
1 document(s) found for C5
2 document(s) found for BERLINGO VP (M59)
2 document(s) found for DISPATCH I & II
1 document(s) found for XM II
1 document(s) found for XSARA PICASSO
2 document(s) found for BERLINGO VU
1 document(s) found for ZX
2 document(s) found for BERLINGO VP
3 document(s) found for C5 (X7)
2 document(s) found for XSARA
2 document(s) found for RELAY II

[BX]

As far as I can see from fitting starters, practically all the 1.9 and 2litre HDI starters are interchangeable. I know that a starter from a 405 1.9 diesel will fit the 2.0l 16 valve HDI. 1.4 & 1.6 HDI engines have the starter fitted to the back of the engine. They probably can interchange I.e between 1.4 & 1.6.

[Peter.N.]

I think the main difference is that the early ones didn't have the reduction gearing but they will all work.

Peter