which is best a xantia or an C5 ?

imperial21 · Post by **imperial21** » 21 Sep 2010, 20:01

I have an 1999 HDI xantia exclusive and when its time to replace it am i better off trying to find a better xantia or move on to a C5 ?
I have read alot of bad things about a C5 i just wonder if they are that bad ? Must be diesel still !

Post by **RichardW** » 21 Sep 2010, 20:20

Trouble with Xantias these days is that the yougest of them are 9 years old, and they are few and far between - currently <100 for sale on Autotrader. Most are now high mileage bangers, so a search for a better one than you have got is likely to be long and most likely fruitless....

C5s can have some issues, but decent ones easily do starship mileage. A lexia is really necessary if you are going to work on one, but they can be had for not much more than a couple of dealer diagnostic sessions! Not driven a C5 much - but I do fancy the idea of a 2.2 HDi twin turbo with >170 BHP!

tim leech · Post by **tim leech** » 21 Sep 2010, 20:27

Best thing to do is find a nice one, drive it and make up your own mind, its true there's quite a bit of bad press about the C5 out there and the Citroenian seems to highlight that, but again finding a nice low mileage Xantia isn't easy these days either.

There is more to go wrong on a C5 as is with all new cars, personally Ive never been a fan of them, finding them aesthetically rather unappealing and nothing special to drive. But again thats my opinion, I'm told the later face-lifted cars are better (and far better looking imho).

Post by **CitroJim** » 21 Sep 2010, 20:31

I'd agree with Richard, good Xantias are now few and far between and getting rarer by the day. Good ones do occasionally turn up though.

If your current Xantia is basically sound, it's well worth looking after it, doing any work needed and sticking with it. Better the devil you know...

I will be keeping mine until the C6 reaches Xantia prices and then I may swap.

Xantias will do starship mileages too. My MK1 V6 is currently on 173000 miles...

imperial21 · Post by **imperial21** » 21 Sep 2010, 21:06

interesting views so far, my xantia has about 108k miles so i hope has a few miles left on it, i really like it to drive but i sometimes think its a bit of a money pit !!! is that citroen motoring ? but as i say i really like my car and its the top model with leather etc !!! but a bit scruffy which i am slowly improving.

rmunns · Post by **rmunns** » 21 Sep 2010, 21:15

FWIW I got a year 2000 Xantia 90Hdi saloon last year at 38000miles, one owner from new, full service etc. Now done 55000 miles, no probs whatsoever, just fitted front discs and pads.
What could be better.

Post by **CitroJim** » 21 Sep 2010, 21:17

108K is just nicely run in!

The funny thing about a Xantia is they can go through a phase of being a money pit and then run very reliably and with little expense for a very long time. This has been my experience with all the ones I've owned. Initially they have consumed a fair bit to get them up to scratch and then very little since.

Huge amounts of money can be saved by doing anything that needs doing yourself and nothing on a Xantia is really beyond competent DIY. Many jobs are straightforward but time-consuming and this is why it is expensive if the work is carried out by dealers...

red_dwarfers · Post by **red_dwarfers** » 21 Sep 2010, 21:18

A least with a Xantia although there are more pits to put money into, they are relatively small compared to the fewer but larger pits that C5s may have.

And of course what with Xantia supplies drying up, you will be hard pressed to find a good one in a few years whereas C5s will be about for much longer.

HDI Dave · Post by **HDI Dave** » 21 Sep 2010, 21:18

I agree with all the above replys,
Xants are getting older,mainly the bodywork I'd say seems to be 'going' now,but I'm far from an expert.

My friends got an early c5 when I got my xant, they prefer mine! Their c5 costs more to repair,more to go wrong, interior is boring, and it looks like a bloody jelly mold...

I'd stick with your own for a bit or dare I say it look for a *less expensive to fix marque.

* In nearly 30 years of motoring,fixing 95% of my/family/other mates cars, I've never put so much work into fixing French stuff... cars AND bikes

Xaccers · Post by **Xaccers** » 21 Sep 2010, 21:32

I would say that most of the "money pit" costs of Xantias is due to poor servicing, and that's even with full service history.
Spheres and LHM don't get changed when they need to be, putting more stress on the pump etc.
Seals, now 10 years old, start failing and need replacing.
Cam belt and water pump need changing, heater matrix is old and leaking, radiator starts dribbling.
Clutch wears out.
It all adds up, but once done, you have a car that doesn't need anything major for another 10 years.

That makes Xantias worth it.

imperial21 · Post by **imperial21** » 21 Sep 2010, 21:50

In many ways the answers sugest the xantia is the better car ?

too me i think its simpler eg no dual mass flywheel, complicated emmision controls.

but as you say they are getting older,but mine has no rust,yet !

Work i have done recently is timming belt,tensioner,water pump. clutch, all rear sphears,LHM fluid change being done this week.
at the moment i am having work done by garages as i have nt got the confedence yet to do the work myself, i have found this forum invalueable for advice.

Xaccers · Post by **Xaccers** » 21 Sep 2010, 21:58

Stick with the Xantia basically.
You'll spend less and it looks better

frenchcarnut · Post by **frenchcarnut** » 21 Sep 2010, 22:04

I'm not going to repeat what everyone has said but just to offer one or two opinions having owned both: the Xantia looks and rides better whilst offering better all round driving visibility. For a big car, the Xantia is far easier to park than the C5 IMHO. And as far as DIY servicing goes - the C5 frightens the life out of me in a way the Xantia never did.

bencowell · Post by **bencowell** » 21 Sep 2010, 23:10

RichardW wrote: Not driven a C5 much - but I do fancy the idea of a 2.2 HDi twin turbo with >170 BHP!

Very good idea to want one too. Fab driveability, Hydractive 3+ suspension and mine averaged 46mpg over the last 18 months.

I've no plans to sell it though.

XantiaDaveEire · Post by **XantiaDaveEire** » 21 Sep 2010, 23:26

Xantias dont rust either !!!